蓝林网 > 国际社会 > 正文

[2021-11-28]巴基斯坦防务论坛:印度科学家称印度的太空技术比中国先进

文章原始标题:Indian space program more advanced than Chinese: Scientist
国外来源地址:https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/indian-space-program-more-advanced-than-chinese-scientist.728185
该译文由蓝林网编辑,转载请声明来源(蓝林网)

内容简介:太空科学家RM Vasagam教授说:“印度的太空计划和印度航天局进行的研究比中国的航太机构先进得多,因为我们自主开发了技术,并且没有依赖其他国家。”

Beast
Indian space program more advanced than Chinese: Scientist
The Indian space program and the research conducted by ISRO is much more advanced than the Chinese space agencies as we have indigenously developed the technology and have not been dependent on other countries, said Padma Prof. RM Vasagam
Another so called indian scientist. Can't believe these fool can be scientist for indian agency head.

引用《科学家:印度太空计划比中国先进》
太空科学家RM Vasagam教授说:“印度的太空计划和印度航天局进行的研究比中国的航太机构先进得多,因为我们自主开发了技术,并且没有依赖其他国家。”
另一个所谓的印度科学家。不敢相信这些傻瓜会成为负责印度机构的科学家。

Dungeness
lol, how can this people be so shameless?
Space Launch 2021:#1

哈哈,这人怎么会这么无耻呢?
太空发射次数:

xyxmt
you are lucky that you do not understand their Language, our bad luck that we do and when we listen to their so called experts on their national TVs giving their expert opinion about their comparison with Chinese economy, military and technology.....and in so many ways they are far ahead of you. Running over Pakistan army is like a walk in the park for them and the only reason they have not destroyed Pakistan is because then they will have to deal with few smaller Pakistan.
IT IS REALLY AN ENTERTAINMENT

你很幸运,你听不懂他们的语言,不知道我们运气有多差,当我们听到他们所谓的专家在他们的国家电视上就他们与中国经济、军事和技术的比较发表专家意见的时候... 并称在许多方面,他们都远远领先于你们。对他们来说,碾过巴基斯坦军队就像在公园里散步一样,他们没有摧毁巴基斯坦的唯一原因是,因为那样他们将不得与一些较小的巴基斯坦打交道。
这真的是一种娱乐。

PAKISTANFOREVER
india is the most advanced nation on the planet.

印度是这个星球上最先进的国家。

lonelyman
stupid author say Indians don't rely on others - yes yes like their pathetic useless 1kg mars probe don't rely on NASA deep space network for control
their cryogenic engine of pathetic rocket is bought from russia
Indians = fake news = garbage = bullshit with open mouth

这个愚蠢的作者说印度人不依赖别人——是是,就像他们可怜无用的一千克火星探测器,不依赖NASA的深空网络来控制一样。
他们的低温火箭发动机是从俄罗斯买来的
印度人=假新闻=废话,张着嘴胡说

AZMwi
because it runs on cow piss and dung

因为它是靠牛尿和牛粪驱动的

Big_bud
I didn't know cow mutra could also make you high!

我不知道牛尿还能人嗨起来!

waz
Don't you know 36% of scientists in NASA are of Indian origin?
China landed on Mars.
China will open its space station.
There is no comparison, the man is an idiot.

你难道不知道美国宇航局36%的科学家都是印度裔吗?
中国登陆火星。
中国将开放空间站。
没什么可比的,这个专家是个白痴。

Beast
He talk as he know anything about China space research. In fact, he is just deluding himself with all the BS he talks. His indian manned mission crew are all training in Russia now. No different from China first manned mission where Yang Liwei was also send to Russia to train as astronaut.
He can delude himself indian don't depend on anybody for their space research or mission.
Currently, China handle all astronaut training by CNSA. The many decades of experience already help China to master all the necessary skill needed to nurture an astronaut by ourselves.

他说得好像他对中国的太空研究了如指掌。事实上,他只是在用他所说的废话欺骗自己。他的印度载人任务人员现在都在俄罗斯接受训练。与中国第一次载人飞行任务没有什么区别,杨利伟也曾被送到俄罗斯进行宇航员训练。
他可以自欺欺人,印度人不依赖任何人进行太空研究或任务。
目前,中国所有的航天员培训都由中国航天局负责。几十年的经验已经帮助中国掌握了自己培养宇航员所需的一切必要技能。

Sugarcane
I do agree with Author, Hindustan had space technology in Vedic times that will give you idea how advance Hindustani space program is now.

我同意作者的观点,印度斯坦在吠陀时代就拥有太空技术,这会让你了解印度斯坦的太空计划现在有多么的先进。

Globenim
Well, good for them?

好吧,对他们有好处吗?

MH.Yang
Modi: India's space program is more advanced than China. We will land on the sun.
Indian reporter: how can we land when the sun is so hot?
Modi: we can land on it at night!
RSS members cheer: Jai Hind, superpower India!
……

莫迪:印度的太空计划比中国先进。我们将在太阳上着陆。
印度记者: 太阳这么热,我们怎么着陆呢?
莫迪:我们可以在晚上降落!
RSS成员欢呼:印度万岁,超级大国印度!
……

Azadkashmir
wrong jealous chinese member, indian will rub cow sh it all over themselves and spaceship. you all jealous because we invented sh it.


错了,嫉妒的中国人们,印度人将把牛粪涂满自己和宇宙飞船上。你们都在嫉妒,因为我们发明了牛粪的用途。

GS Zhou
Let me tell you who has the world's best space technology! It's Bhutan! Because Bhutan has ZERO failure launch records in the past 100 years! Amazing!

让我告诉你们谁拥有世界上最好的太空技术!那是不丹!因为不丹在过去的一百年里有零次失败的发射记录!厉害了!

Shotgunner51
Orbital launch has become too common in China these days, it's just a walk in the park for CNSA! Even many private startup companies are joining the game. Nowadays people talk about progress of orbital infrastructure, deep space.

如今,轨道发射在中国已经变得非常普遍了,对中国航天局来说,这不过是在公园里散步!甚至许多私人创业公司也加入了这场游戏。现在人们谈论轨道基础设施的进步,深空。

GiantPanda
China has 44 launches (so far, could be 50 by year's end) vs India's 2 (one of which failed) and India is better in space than China?
Are these people really that delusional? How could Indians even make that statement when they can't even launch more than a handful compared to the dozens that China does year after year?
This is like a team losing 44-2 and then telling everyone watching that they are better than the team beating the absolute crap out of them.
I'm sorry but this is epic mental retardation at the national level. LOL

中国有44次发射(到目前为止,今年年底可能达到50次),印度有2次发射(其中1次失败了),印度在太空领域比中国好?
这些人真的有妄想症吗?与中国年复一年发射的几十次相比,印度甚至连几次都发射不了,他们怎么能说出这样的话呢?
这就像是一支以44-2输掉比赛的球队,然后告诉所有观众,他们比把他们打得屁滚尿流的球队更好。
我很抱歉,但这是国家级的罕见智障。哈哈

Shotgunner51
2 failed launches this year were made by a Beijing-based private startup doing their trials, the company has done two rounds of VC financing, still early stage, wish them do better next time. The rest 42 launches by state-run CNSA are 100% successful, impeccable maturity and top notch China quality.

今年有2次发射失败,是由一家北京的民营初创企业进行的试验,该公司已经进行了两轮风险投资,仍处于早期阶段,希望他们下次能做得更好。其余的42次由中国国营的中国航天局发射,100%成功,无可挑剔的成熟度和一流的中国质量。

Beast
They will claim covid-19 delay. If not covid-19 , they would have make 1000 launch for that years.
They will also claim their ISRO technology advancement is delay by low budget, if you give them USD 1 trillion. They would have already capture the sun and bring aliens on earth...
Its Indian culture, they will blame any wrong on others. They can never be wrong. Indian is perfect.

他们会宣称因新冠疫情而推迟,如果不是新冠疫情,他们会在那几年里进行1000次发射。
他们还会声称他们的印度航天局技术进步是因为低预算而被推迟,如果你给他们1万亿美元。他们可能已经捕获了太阳并把外星人带到了地球上...
这是印度文化,他们会把任何错误归咎于别人。他们永远不会错。印度是完美的。

Pakistan Space Agency
I just dont get why Indians can't keep their gobs shut? Why do they have to brag all the time?

我只是不明白为什么印度人就不能闭嘴?为什么他们总是吹牛?

Bilal9
They have to brag because these ignorant Sanghis have to feed their fragile egos.
I say ignorant because you can have five IT coolie tech degrees, yet no real understanding where the India is compared to world or where it is going.
It is one thing to keep quiet and show in deeds instead of words.
Screaming "I'm world's best!" when you are not, will only make you a butt of jokes. A feeble attempt to convince voters at home.
For Allah's sake, most of the modern tech used in India nowadays, is supplied by China. Cellphones are just the start.
Most of these cow belt Sanghis are village dehati idiots and they are dragging India's name through the mud.
Indian media has been hijacked by these idiots.
No one in India can speak against Modi or his stupid nationalist propaganda, otherwise they won't have a job or livelihood.
The more nationalist/propagandist one is in India, the better their job and promotion prospects nowadays.

他们不得不吹牛,因为这些无知的莫迪信徒必须满足他们脆弱的自我。
我之所以说无知,是因为你可以拥有五个IT苦力技术学位,但却不能真正理解与世界相比印度在什么位置,它将走向何方。
保持沉默,用行动代替言语是一回事。
大喊着“我是世界上最优秀的!”,当你不是的时候,只会让你成为笑柄。试图说服国内选民的无力尝试。
看在真主的份上,现在印度使用的大部分现代技术都是由中国提供的。手机只是个开始。
这些莫迪信徒中的大多数都是村里的白痴,他们正在把印度的名声拖入泥潭。
印度媒体已经被这些白痴劫持了。
在印度,没有人可以反对莫迪或者他愚蠢的民族主义宣传,否则他们就没有工作和生计。
印度的民族主义者/宣传者越多,他们现在的工作和晋升前景就越好。

siegecrossbow
I take it that being so advanced, they’ve completed three Lunar soft landings, launched their own space station, and are readying a rover for Mars?

我想,他们如此先进,已经完成了三次月球软着陆,发射了他们自己的空间站,并且正在为火星漫游车做准备?

mike2000 is back
Indian should stop being obsssessed with China. They should have their own objectives instead of copying the Chinese and always trying to compare themselves to them. It rediculous.

印度应该停止迷恋中国。他们应该有自己的目标,而不是模仿中国人,总是试图把自己和中国人比较。这太荒谬了。

FairAndUnbiased
If Indians copied China I would be worried. Thankfully their arrogance prevents that.

如果印度抄袭中国,我会感到担忧的。幸亏他们的傲慢阻止了这情况。

vishwambhar
I wont say we are ahead in space but we are equal in space technology..... However China have a deep pockets so the outcome seen from their space program is faster than India's.....

我不会说我们在太空中领先,但是我们在太空技术方面是一样的...然而,中国财力雄厚,所以他们的太空计划的结果比印度的要快...

Dungeness
You have an auto rickshaw and I drive a BMW, so we are equal in "transportation technology?

你有一辆三轮摩托车,我开一辆宝马,所以我们在“运输技术”方面是平等的?

vishwambhar
Off course if question is about "transportation technology"..... Auto rickshaw can drop me at the location where BMW can......

当然,如果问题是关于“运输技术”... 三轮摩托车可以把我送到跟宝马一样的地点...

lonelyman
Indian stupidity and shameless know bounds,
a country pays French to launch heavy satellites say we are equal with China, which landed a Mars rover and collected and returned Moon sample
indians will say supa powa india is the same as nasa in terms of technology , it’s just we are shitty poor , so the outcome looks USA is faster
All these Pajeets IQ

印度人的愚蠢和无耻是有界限的,
一个花钱请法国发射重型卫星的国家说,我们和中国一样,而中国发射了一辆火星漫游车、收集并送回了月球样本。
印度人会说,在技术方面,超级大国印度和NASA一样,只是我们太穷了,所以结果看起来美国更快
所有这些帕吉特人的智商啊

siegecrossbow
Shouldn't measures be taken to improve the depth of your pockets instead of using it as an excuse?

难道不应该采取措施来改善你的口袋深度,而不是用它作为一个借口?

Bilal9
Their hunger level and GDP per capita are both worse than Bangladesh.
Screwing their own poor people (which we don't do in Bangladesh) didn't help either.
For example, they could easily improve their education system and school retention rates by just imposing minimal tariff on gold imports but won't do it.
Brahmin upper class needs their cheap gold as asset.

他们的饥饿水平和人均GDP都比孟加拉国更差。
压榨他们自己的穷人也无济于事(我们孟加拉国不这样做)。
例如,他们可以通过对黄金进口征收最低关税来轻松改善他们的教育系统和学校保留率,但是他们不会这样做。
婆罗门的上层阶级需要廉价的黄金作为资产。

GS Zhou
But that's too difficult and painful. By blabla on the internet, supa Indian can achieve anything!

但是这太难太痛苦了,通过在网上的吹嘘,印度人可以实现任何事情!

siegecrossbow
CNSA’s budget is a pitiful fraction of NASA or even Musk’s, but that doesn’t stop them from making record number of launches this year. Budget is no excuse for incompetence.

中国航天局的预算只是NASA甚至马斯克预算的一小部分,但这并不能阻止他们今年创纪录的发射次数。预算不是无能的借口。

Beast
Equal what equal? You mean your crash turtle on Moon can compare to Intact Yutu 2 on far side of the moon?
and how about space station? Can you build a space core module? Can you know how to dock? Then Beidou 3 is worldwide service and can provide better accuracy than US GPS and signal can penetrate underground.
You are talking nonsense. Tell me one you think India space is equal with China.. China and India space are not on the same level.
China is space power while India is just trying to be a rising space nation and south asia regional lead.

相等是什么相等?你的意思是你们在月球上的坠落乌龟可以和在月球背面完好无损的玉兔2号相比?
那空间站呢?你们能建造一个太空核心舱吗?你知道怎么对接吗?然后北斗三号是全球服务,可以提供比美国GPS更高的精度,而且信号可以穿透地下。
你就是在胡说八道。告诉我一个你认为印度太空技术和中国是相等的方面... 中国和印度的太空技术不在同一水平上。
中国是太空强国,而印度只是在努力成为一个正在崛起的航天大国和南亚地区的领导者。

vishwambhar
You are misunderstanding my post.... We too have such technology like building space station etc but budget stops us.... For china budget is no issue.....

你误解了我的评论... 我们也有这样的技术,如建造空间站等,但预算阻止了我们... 对中国来说,预算不是问题...

GS Zhou
You know what? I can play soccer as good as Cristiano Ronaldo. But budget stops me, because I cannot afford the expensive soccer shoes as him. For Cristiano Ronaldo budget is no issue...


你知道吗?我的足球踢得和克里斯蒂亚诺·罗纳尔多一样好。但是预算阻止了我,因为我买不起像他那样昂贵的足球鞋。对于克里斯蒂亚诺·罗纳尔多来说,预算不是问题...

doorstar
yeah... and I could be flying a Boing 747 or a B52 bomber as a hobby instead of my paper origami airplane but the damned budget won't allow it otherwise I am as good as any pilot of a bomber or a passenger jet.
God darn this budget, amen!

是啊...我可以把驾驶波音747或者B52轰炸机当作业余爱好,而不是折纸飞机,但是该死的预算不允许,否则我就和任何一个轰炸机或者客机的飞行员一样优秀了。
就是这预算的锅,阿门!

Beast
Absolutely nonsense, just an excuse to mask your inferiority. Everything shitty thing blame on budget? So in your case, india has zero fault. What an pathetic mentality. But I am happy , u can keep delude yourself so that Indian will never work hard. Just keep deceive themselves.

完全就是扯淡,只是一个掩饰你自卑的借口。所有糟糕的事情都归咎于预算?所以就你的情况而言,印度没有任何缺陷。多么可悲的心态啊。但是我很高兴,你可以继续欺骗自己,这样印度人就永远不会努力工作。只是不断自欺欺人。

lonelyman
not everything can be blamed on no money
like sub Sahara Africa countries are poor as well, I don’t see them open shit on streets
They don’t have habit of throwing garbages on streets or dump into their holy river
massive rape problems in Indian society as well

不是所有的事都能归咎于没钱
就像撒哈拉以南的非洲国家也很贫穷,我没看到他们在大街上拉屎
他们没有把垃圾扔在街上或者倒进他们圣河的习惯
印度社会也存在大规模的强奸问题

EternalMortal
A donkey cart can drop you off to the same place too. You now gonna claim they're equal in tech as well?

驴车也可以把你送到同一个地方。你现在要宣称他们在技术上是平等的吗?

vishwambhar
Yes off course if the question is genuinely asked about TRANSPORTATION TECHNOLOGY..... only lacking thing will be speed and comfort but it will serve purpose for sure.....

如果问题是关于运输技术的,那么当然可以... 唯一缺少的就是速度和舒适度,但它肯定能达到目的...

lonelyman
indians like to argue, defend stupidity with stupidity
did you get there? Did you land Rover on Mars and moon? Did you collect sample from moon? Did you build space station and have astronauts living there for half year ?
come back after u did this , then u can argue the same transportation technology, though yours is smaller and primitive
don’t give me we are dirt poor excuse, Somali can make the same argument

印度人喜欢争辩,用愚蠢来捍卫愚蠢
你们到了吗?你们在火星和月球上登陆月球车了吗?你们从月球上采集样本了吗?你们建造了空间站并让航天员在那里生活半年吗?
等你们实现这些后再回来,你就可以争论有同样的运输技术了,虽然你们的技术更小更原始
不要给我“我们非常穷”的借口,索马里人也可以这样说

Nan Yang
India's space program is not sustainable without a solid foundation.

如果没有坚实的基础,印度的太空计划是不可持续的。

Sainthood 101
Budget is everything though...
Many countries can have technology if they're determined
Pak was one of the pioneers in spaceflights atleast in Asia, now not a lot on space front even though infrastructure is probably there that if you decide to truly focus and be dedicated something can come out of it , graduates of aranautical programs are still graduating and getting hired by foreign companies, so basics of a space program is always there in most decent countries
You need 2 things to be a space country massive.will and massive amounts of money

虽然预算就是一切...
许多国家都可以拥有技术,只要他们有决心
至少在亚洲,巴基斯坦是航天领域的先驱之一,现在在太空方面没有什么进展,尽管基础设施可能存在,如果你决定真正关注并致力于此,就会有成果,航天专业的毕业生仍在毕业并被外国公司雇用,所以在大多数体面的国家,太空项目的基本要素始终存在。
要成为一个太空强国,你需要两样东西:意志和大量的金钱。

Shotgunner51
There are two ways of getting monies.
Easy way, you scramble the money printer. Buy whatever needed, rocket boosters, components/parts, tools, as well as immigrants from all over the world bringing their ideas/techs to you. See how a South African build his private space company in the the world's largest money printer/exporter. You only need to make sure what you print is good as gold.
Or do it the hard way, build a competitive economy to earn the money. Even better if it's a Hi-Tech economy, cos during the process you may have amassed some if not all technological knowhow useful for your future space business. This path is tough but perhaps the only choice for most countries, yours and mine included. China Hi-Tech exports amounted to $757 billion last year, more than the next 5 industrial powers (US, Japan, Germany, South Korea, France) combined, or over 5 times that of US, that even excludes HKSAR's $340 billion (partly re-export). A Hi-Tech economy is the foundation for space business.

获得资金有两种方式。
简单的方法,你抢下印钞机。买任何需要的东西,火箭助推器,零部件,工具,还有来自世界各地的移民把他们的想法和技术带给你。看看一个南非人是如何在世界上最大的印钞机/出口商建立他的私人太空公司。你只需要确保你印刷的东西像黄金一样好。
或者复杂的方法,建立一个有竞争力的经济体来赚钱。如果是高科技经济就更好了,因为在这个过程中,你可能已经积累了一些技术知识,即使不是全部。这些技术知识对你未来的太空生意很有用。这条道路很艰难,但也许是包括你我在内的大多数国家的唯一选择。中国去年的高科技出口总额达7570亿美元,超过其后五个工业大国(美国、日本、德国、韩国、法国)的总和,甚至超过美国的五倍,即使不包括香港特区的3,400亿美元(部分再出口)。高科技经济是航天事业的基础。

GiantPanda
You have nothing to show that you anywhere near equal in technology.
There are no Indian equivalent to the Chinese Space Station, the rover on Mars or the rovers on the Moon.
44 launches to 2 tells me that the technology level is not even close. For China, space is now routine. India? Maybe a step above UAE (who also had a Mars orbiter) but not much more.

你没有任何东西可以证明你们在技术方面和他们差不多。
印度没有与中国空间站、火星漫游车或月球漫游车相当的东西。
44次发射相比2次发射,告诉我,技术水平甚至差的很远。对于中国来说,太空现在已经是家常便饭。印度?也许比阿联酋(也有火星轨道器)高一级,但仅此而已。

Beidou2020
As I’ve been saying, dumbest group of humans on earth. Their political elite, their military elite, their scientific elite are all no different to your average Indian internet trolls.

就像我说的,地球上最愚蠢的一群人。他们的政治精英,他们的军事精英,他们的科学精英和一般的印度网络喷子没有什么不同。

Dungeness
It's like they were from an entirely different species of Homo sapiens, different thought process, different logic, different common sense, different work ethic, defferent honor code, defferent inspiration........
We work our axx out, and they TALK their axx out.

就好像他们来自一个完全不同的智人物种,不同的思维过程,不同的逻辑,不同的常识,不同的职业道德,不同的荣誉准则,不同的灵感...
我们工作不止,他们喋喋不休。

GiantPanda
So basically Indian internet trolls are just regular Indians.
What a race of delusional crazies. lol

所以基本上印度的网络喷子只是普通的印度人。
真是一群有妄想症的疯子。哈哈

Azadkashmir
but but but if we had the new plane we would have beaten pakistan.
but but but we would have been ahead all the world if we wont ruled by Muslims for 1000s years.
but but but Pakistanis are originally Hindus, but they deny it.
but but but india economy is bigger than pakistans
but but but india invented vedic planes before europeans they stole it from us.
but but but they are doing love jihad
but but but taj mahal is bharat mata not muslim.
but but but they are trafficking cow to make it into beef burger
but but but its the muslims fault we are low on resources because they using up the coal to make kebabs.
but but but she was wearing short skirt that why i raped her its her fault i got tempted.
but but but we are more advanced than china

但是但是但是,如果我们有了新飞机,我们就会打败巴基斯坦
但是但是但是,如果我们不是被穆斯林统治1000年的话,我们就会领先于全世界了
但是但是但是,巴基斯坦人本来就是印度教徒,但是他们否认
但是但是但是,印度的经济规模比巴基斯坦还要大
但是但是但是,印度在欧洲人之前就发明了吠陀飞机,他们从我们这里偷走了
但是但是但是,他们在进行爱的圣战
但是但是但是,泰姬陵是印度的而不是穆斯林的
但是但是但是,他们贩卖牛来做牛肉汉堡
但是但是但是,这是穆斯林的错,我们缺乏资源,因为他们用光了煤炭来做烤肉串
但是但是但是,她穿着短裙,所以我强奸了她,是她的错,我被诱惑了
但是但是但是,我们比中国先进

serenity
Out of major space technologies:
Heavy lift vehicles - China has lead in and much more experience and years more developing, building and using.
Manned space flight - China has lead in and much more experience and decades more doing than India which hasn't even done it once yet so maybe not just decades but possibly will be centuries or millennia etc assuming India ever passes this.
EVA - China has lead in and much more experience and years more developing, improving and doing.
Docking tech - China has lead in and much more experience and years more doing.
Rocket engines - China has lead in and heavier thrust, more types, both solid and liquid fuel technologies (cryogenic which India brags a lot about even though it's so basic and common) compared to India's very low tech engines and only a few types.
Testing facilities - China has lead in and much more investment over decades longer than India.
Orbiting and satellite warfare technologies - China has relay types and movable types which India lacks still. For a long time China has been improving satellite warfare tech and they can all take advantage of extremely difficult lagrangian orbits which Indian ones are not yet capable of. Again years more experience in doing. Decades more experience in development and testing. American and Chinese satellites have been at war maneuvers in space for years now. Indian satellites don't even work well while China is performing maneuvers only two nations on earth can do currently.
Lander technology - China has performed 3 major and difficult soft landings with success. India has yet to perform one successfully.
Rover technology - China has successfully operated 3 rovers with two on the moon and one on Mars. India has zero.
Space station technology - China operated space lab Tiangong 1 for nearly 7 years before deorbiting that trial station and starting the current space station program which has many modules already and several missions. India has not yet deployed even a space lab with one small module.
Launch facilities - China has much more launch facilities than India and building more than India at a faster rate than India. It also is developing several ship launchers with already many built and used for years while India has yet to develop a single ship launcher.
Spacecraft - China has Shenzhou spacecraft developed from Soyuz, since 1999. India has yet to develop a single spacecraft. It is already more than 20 years behind China just on this. Shenzhou is much larger and more modern and advanced than Soyuz despite being developed using Soyuz technology purchased from Russia. But this is 22 years old as a launched spacecraft but over 30 years old as a piece of technology that was developed back then. China now has flown the Next Generation Spacecraft (one of the world's most modern and advanced multi crew spacecraft) two times successfully once in 2016 and once in 2020 with unmanned trials and landing them back safely inside China. India only has powerpoint spacecraft programs.
Deep Space Network - China has it's own since 1980s and India to this day still requires US and European assistance with deep space network and borrow others to perform any space mission that requires DSN.
All of these are the main components of space technologies and China is ahead of India in development, building, testing, and using. India offers few launch services and no one is buying Indian space launch services these days, only one customer every few years. Not even Indian government buys many Indian space launch services.
Private or non-national space sector, China has over 10 organizations involved and have been launching and developing multiple techs on their own for years now. Some affiliated with government have access to national space technologies and suppliers but many are doing it all themselves. It is young but it is far ahead of India's in developing and doing.
Oh and Beidou/Compass is many times more advanced than the Indian failed project GNS which is not even functioning properly while Beidou coverage for Asia region is superior to even GPS of US with even more accuracy and allows for active multiway direct communication with even ground commercial user level which GPS still does not yet offer.
India has not even been able to develop something similar to Longmarch 3 level, it will need decades more to get to Longmarch 7 and Longmarch 5 level.

除了主要的太空技术之外:
重型运载火箭——中国领先,中国在开发、建造和使用重型运载火箭方面拥有更多的经验。
载人航天飞行——中国领先,有更多的经验和几十年的作为,印度甚至一次都没做过,因此,假设印度能够超越这个水平的话,可能不仅仅是几十年,可能是几百年甚至几千年等等。
舱外活动——中国领先,有更多的经验和更多的发展、改进和行动。
对接技术——中国领先,有更多的经验和多年实践。
火箭发动机——与印度低技术发动机和仅有的几种类型相比,中国在固体和液体燃料技术方面处于领先地位,推力更大,种类更多(印度吹嘘低温技术,尽管这种技术非常基础和普遍)。
测试设施——中国领先,几十年来的投资比印度多得多。
轨道和卫星作战技术——中国有中继型和可移动型,而印度仍然缺乏。很长一段时间以来,中国一直在改进卫星作战技术,他们已经可以利用极其困难的拉格朗日轨道,而印度还不具备这能力。再说一次,这是长年累月的经验积累。数十年的开发和测试经验。美国和中国的卫星已经在太空进行了多年的军事演习。印度的卫星甚至不能很好地工作,而中国的卫星正在进行目前世界上只有两个国家能做到的机动演习。
着陆器技术——中国已经成功地完成了3次重要和困难的软着陆。印度迄今尚未成功实现这一目标。
漫游车技术——中国已经成功运行了3辆漫游车,其中2辆在月球上,1辆在火星上。印度没有。
空间站技术——中国运营空间实验室“天宫一号”近7年,之后将该试验站脱离轨道,启动目前的空间站计划,该计划已经拥有多个模块和多项任务。印度甚至还没有部署一个只有一个小模块的太空实验室。
发射设施——中国的发射设施比印度多得多,建设速度也比印度快。它还在开发若干舰载火箭发射器,而印度尚未开发出一个舰载火箭发射器。
航天器——自1999年以来,中国有从联盟号发展而来地神舟飞船。印度还没有开发出一艘航天器。仅在这一点上,印度已经落后20多年了。尽管神州飞船是使用从俄罗斯购买的联盟号技术开发的,但它比联盟号更大、更现代、更先进。但是作为一艘发射的航天器,它已经有22年的历史了,但是作为一项当时开发的技术,它已经有30多年的历史了。中国现在已经两次成功发射了下一代航天器(世界上最现代和最先进的多人航天器之一),一次是在2016年,另一次是在2020年,进行了无人驾驶试验并安全着陆回中国。印度只有幻灯片的航天器项目。
深空网络——中国自80年代以来就拥有自己的深空网络,印度至今仍然需要美国和欧洲在深空网络方面的援助,并借用其他国家来执行任何需要深空网络的太空任务。
所有这些都是太空技术的主要组成部分,中国在开发、建造、测试和使用方面领先于印度。印度提供的发射服务很少,现在也没有人购买印度的太空发射服务,每隔几年只有一个客户。甚至印度政府也没有购买很多印度的太空发射服务。
无论是私营或是非国家太空部门,中国有10多个组织参与,多年来一直在自主发射和开发多种技术。一些隶属于政府的公司可以获得国家太空技术和供应商,但许多公司都是自己做的。中国虽然年轻,但在发展和实践方面远远领先于印度。
哦,北斗比印度失败的GNS项目先进很多倍,GNS甚至无法正常运行,而且北斗对亚洲地区的覆盖甚至比美国的GPS更高,精度更高,甚至允许与地面商业用户进行活跃的多路直接通信,而GPS仍然不能提供这种服务。
印度甚至还没能开发出类似于长征3号的东西,它还需要几十年才能达到长征7号和长征5号的水平。

Shotgunner51
Yes, not to mention all the constellations China owns in the orbits, from Infra-red to Gaofen to Fengyun to Beidou ... I've lost count!
China Space Military:Recon, Satcom, Navi, ASAT/BMD, Orbital Vehicle, etc.

是的,更不用说中国在轨道上拥有的所有卫星了,从红外线到高分,从风云到北斗……我都数不清了!
中国航天军事:侦察、卫星通信、导航、反卫星/弹道导弹、轨道飞行器,等。

newb3e
Modi g built a Mandir on mars so yes Indians are supa asssmart and supa advance!

莫迪G在火星上建造了一座寺庙,所以是的,印度人超级聪明、超级进步!

GS Zhou
By the moment I'm writing the thread, China has:
- a rover on the Mars
- a rover on the far side of the moon
- three taikonauts working and living in China's own space station;
Since supa India is a "flee media" country, these news must have been reported there.

在我回复这个帖子的时候,中国已经有:
-火星漫游车
-月球背面漫游车
-三名中国航天员在中国自己的空间站工作和生活;
由于“超级大国”印度是一个“逃避媒体”的国家,这些新闻一定是在那里报道的。