[2021-02-17]我们可以从希特勒身上学到什么积极的东西？

Saugata Deb Nath Senior QA Analyst at Wells Fargo (2018-present)
Okay first let me be clear, Hitler no matter how cool, strong, great leader he might look always remember that he is one of the most evil person to ever walk on this planet. A cold heart dictator who had absolutely no regards for human life.
I myself have studied about Hitler and Second World war for the past 11-12 years. Western Historians definitely try to portray him in a much evil way(as if he had nothing good in him) but there are definitely some facts about Hitler that you may find interesting
1. He was an absolute nationalist. loved his country a lot(Hitler is Austrian born but ethnically German) and tried his best to take Germany to its pinnacle, though his path wasn't the right one

【回答】富国银行高级QA分析师(2018年-至今)
好吧，首先让我澄清一下，希特勒无论看起来有多酷，有多强壮，是多伟大的领袖，都要永远记得他是这个星球上最邪恶的人之一。一个冷酷无情，罔顾人命的独裁者。
在过去的11年到12年里，我自己也一直研究过希特勒和二战。毫无疑问，西方历史学家试图用一种邪恶的方式来描绘希特勒(好像他没有什么好的一面) ，但是关于希特勒的一些事实你肯定会感兴趣。
1、他是一个绝对的民族主义者。他非常热爱自己的国家(希特勒出生于奥地利，但是是德国人) ，并且尽最大努力把德国带到巅峰，尽管他的道路并不正确

2. Hitler was a vegan and didn't encourage cruelty towards animal, he made many laws to stop hunting, animal slaughter. His love towards animal is commendable
3. He did succeed in removing inflation, poverty and unemployment. During his rule, Germany had a negligible percentage of unemployment. Did a lot of public work. Within just a few years he built roads, bridges, factories, industrial centers that helped Germany regain its economic status.
4. True leader, knew how to control his group. Disciplined.
5.He wanted to be an artist but never did succeed much with his career as an artist. I suppose he had good aesthetic values
6. Last and the most important, HE IS PROBABLY THE GREATEST orator to be born. Try to download and here some of his public speeches. You would get goosebumps.
He killed 6 million jews in an organized manner and destroyed half of Europe to rubble, so as a person there was more evil in him than good qualities.

2、希特勒是个纯素主义者，他不鼓励对动物的残忍行为，他制定了很多法律来禁止打猎，屠宰。他对动物的爱是值得表扬的。
3、他成功地消除了通货膨胀、贫穷和失业。在他执政期间，德国的失业率可以忽略不计。做了很多公共工作。在短短几年内，他修建了道路、桥梁、工厂和工业中心，帮助德国重新获得了经济地位。
4、真正的领导者，知道如何控制自己的团队。
5、他想成为一名艺术家，但他的艺术生涯从未取得多大成功。我想他有很不错的审美观。
6、最后，也是最重要的一点，他可能是最伟大的演说家。试着下载一些他的公开演讲。你会起鸡皮疙瘩的。
他有组织地杀害了600万犹太人，把半个欧洲夷为平地，所以作为一个人，他的邪恶多于优良品质。

Spartacus Olsson Passionate history documentary producer - especially the WWs
Additional positive thing that we can learn from Hitler is that we have to accept that any politician that says he, or she wants to implement policies of oppression to achieve something that we perceive as a greater good - needs to be taken literally, and cannot be supported.
Hitler taught us that when you start talking that way, there is a real and tangible risk that people will die and humanity as a whole will suffer. In other words: thinking something like; “ok he doesn't like Jews, homosexuals, individualists and so on - personally I have nothing against ‘them’, but hey… it's not like he's going to kill ‘them’, and if cutting down their freedom a bit is the cost of getting our economy back on its feet, then we’ll have to live with that.” That's the way many Germans thought in the early thirties - as we know they were tragically wrong - both in the killing and the economy…

【回答】热情的历史纪录片制片人，特别是世界大战系列
我们可以从希特勒那里学到的另一个积极的东西是——我们必须接受这样一个事实：任何政治家，只要说他或她想实施压迫政策来实现我们认为是更大的利益的东西，就需要从字面上理解，而不能得到支持。
希特勒告诉我们，当你开始这样说的时候，就会有真实而切实的危险，那就是人们将会死去，整个人类将会遭受痛苦。换句话说，这样想：“好吧，他不喜欢犹太人、同性恋者、个人主义者等等，就我个人而言，我并不反对‘他们’，但是，嘿... 并不是说要杀掉‘他们’，如果稍微减少他们的自由是让我们的经济重新站稳脚跟的代价，那么我们将不得不接受这个条件。”这是许多德国人在30年代初的想法，我们知道他们悲剧性地错了，无论是在杀戮还是在经济上...

Every time the Nazis implemented public policies of oppression and murder they suffered public support backlashes - but that was too late, because they were already in power and could quench that opposition with the executive, murderous power of the state.
Anything else like anti-smoking campaigns, or free holidays for workers on the coast, or the autobahn are BS as they weren't his ideas, and not unique to the Nazis.

每当纳粹实施压迫和谋杀的公共政策时，他们都会遭到公众的强烈反对——但那已经太晚了，因为他们已经掌权，而且可以用国家的行政权力来平息这种反对。
其他任何事情，比如禁烟运动，或者为沿海工人提供免费假期，或者高速公路，都是扯淡，因为这些不是他的主意，也不是纳粹独有的。

Talat Zehra former Teaching
There are some positive qualities even the worst persons. As for Hitler he was initally not as bad/evil as he became finally. As for his evil acts there is no need to mention it in this answer. They are found in every book of WW2 history.
But as for his positive qualities they are as follow:
* He had a very good choice of words. He should have been a poet instead of a politician.
* He was a man of strong will.
* He was a good administrator.
* He was a lover of art.
* He was super imaginative. (He should be a fiction writer instead of a politician).
* Once he had made a decision whe would stand firm on it inspite of the fact it was proved to be wrong and incorrect.
* He tried to make Third Reich a Supreme Power.

【回答】前教师
即使是最坏的人也有一些积极的品质。至于希特勒，他一开始并没有最后变得那么坏/邪恶。至于他的恶行，没有必要在这个回答中提及。它们出现在二战历史的每一本书中。
至于他的积极品质，有以下几点：
* 他的用词很恰当，他应该成为一名诗人而不是政治家。
* 他是个意志坚强的人。
* 他是个好管理者。
* 他是个艺术爱好者。
* 他超级富有想象力。(他应该是一个小说家而不是一个政治家)。
* 一旦他做出了一个决定，即使事实证明这个决定是错误和不正确的，他还是会坚持下去。
* 他试图让第三帝国成为一个至高无上的强国。

* He initially offered peace offers to the British PM.
* He dislike smoking and drugs.
* He initially had regard for GB and British people.
* He did prefer to commit suicide over surrender.
There are many other qualities in pages of history.
But he had many bad qualities as well. As the question is about good or positive qualities only to discuss his bad/evil and negative qualities is beyond the scope of this answer.

* 他最初向英国首相提出和平建议。
* 他不喜欢吸烟和吸毒。
* 他最初尊重英国和英国人民。
* 他宁愿自杀也不愿投降。
在历史上还有许多其他的品质。
但是他也有很多不好的品质。因为这个问题是关于好的或者积极的品质，仅仅讨论他坏的和消极的品质超出了这个答案的范围。

Vijay Soni works at IDBI Bank
Apparently he was a brilliant orator. It's hard for a non-German speaker to judge but his speeches had a real ability to touch the German people. Which is no mean achievement considering he wasn't even German himself. It takes a special kind of fervour to whip up patriotism and national pride when you're not even from that country.
He was also a man of extreme conviction, which you can clearly see in his speech giving even if you don't understand the language. In uncertain times people are drawn to those who are extremely sure of themselves and convinced of their own beliefs. Hitler wasn't the sort of guy who had any doubts about his mission or ability.
He was incredibly single minded. He didn't chase women, do drugs or abuse his power. He wasn't interested in using his position to gain wealth and personal adornments. He was really, really committed to making Germany the world's superpower and committing genocide.

【回答】在IDBI银行工作
显然，他是一个杰出的演说家。非德语国家的人很难评判，但他的演讲确实触动了德国人民。考虑到他自己都不是德国人，这是一个不小的成就。当你甚至不是来自那个国家的时候，激发爱国主义和民族自豪感需要一种特殊的热情。
他也是一个极端有信念的人，你可以在他的演讲中清楚地看到，即使你不懂他的语言。在不确定的时期，人们会被那些对自己非常有信心并坚信自己信念的人所吸引。希特勒不是那种对自己的使命和能力有任何怀疑的人。
他也是一个非常坚定的人。他不追求女人，不吸毒，也不滥用权力。他对利用自己的地位获取财富和个人装饰物不感兴趣。他真的，真的致力于让德国成为世界超级大国，而犯下了种族灭绝。

He was ruthless. There are lots of political leaders in the world who would love to be able to dispose of their political enemies permanently but don't have the guts. Hitler was happy to have anyone who disagreed with him murdered and to dispose of his political enemies with either the threat of violence or actual violence. It definitely helped him to obtain and hold power.
As long as you're prepared to overlook his total lack of morals, barking insanity and inherently evil ideology he had all the hallmarks of a great leader.

他冷酷无情。世界上有很多政治领袖，他们希望能够永久消灭他们的政敌，但是没有这个胆量。希特勒乐于看到任何与他意见相左的人被杀害，并以暴力威胁或以实际的暴力手段处决他的政敌。这无疑帮助他获得并掌握了权力。
只要你愿意忽略他完全缺乏道德、狂暴和天生邪恶的意识形态，他就拥有一个伟大领袖的所有特征。

Julio Cesar Pino Ph.D from University of California, Los Angeles
What can I say of the Fuhrer? I can only say READ HIM: “The world is ruled by will and the gods grant their love only to those who demand the impossible.”
“I wish to harm no one. But when the survival of the species is at stake I must act.”
“A great man should never marry. It’s much better to take a mistress.”
“The key to understanding Russia is that the Russian is essentially an anarchist.”
“The natural piety of man comes from that awe he feels before the laws of the universe. That is the only religion worth following.”
“No man should attempt any serious work before the age of thirty.”
“Nature does not forgive weakness.”
“No healthy man is a Marxist. The slums are responsible for 90% and drink for 10% of the Marxism in Germany.”

【回答】加州大学洛杉矶分校博士
我能对元首说什么呢？我只能说读他的话：“世界是由意志统治的，神只会把他们的爱给那些要求不可能的人。”
“我不想伤害任何人。但当物种的生存受到威胁时，我必须采取行动。”
“一个伟大的人不应该结婚。找个情妇要好得多。”
“理解俄罗斯的关键在于，俄罗斯人本质上是无政府主义者。”
“人类对自然的虔诚来自于对宇宙法则的敬畏。这是唯一值得信奉的宗教。”
“任何人在三十岁之前都不应该尝试任何严肃的工作。”
“大自然不会原谅软弱。”
“没有一个健康的人是马克思主义者。在德国，90%的马克思主义者来自贫民窟，10%的马克思主义者来自酒徒。”

Mohammad Dayyan
* Nazi regime was the first to introduce animal rights and limited hunting seasons. Hitler had outlawed animal testing (who needs animals when you got thousands of Untermenschen).
* Nazis had the first public anti smoking campaign at a time when smoking was not linked to cancer.
* Hitler had authorized extensive research on cancer and various venereal diseases and abundance of medicine for public.
* Nazi labour laws were best in contemporary world. Reduced work hours, periodic breaks, paid holidays and sponsored trips to Italy as perks.
* Promoted sports culture among youth which led to Germany being a sports power house.
* Hosted the 1936 Berlin Olympics.
* Hitler had announced loans of 1000 Reichsmark (10 month salary in 1939) for married couples at minimal interest and waivers for birth of first child.

【回答】
* 纳粹政权率先引入了动物权利和有季节限制的狩猎。希特勒已经宣布动物实验是非法的(当你有了成千上万的劣等人种时，谁还需要动物呢)。
* 当吸烟还与癌症无关的时候，纳粹发起了第一次公共禁烟运动。
* 希特勒授权对癌症和各种性病进行广泛的研究，并为公众提供大量药物。
* 纳粹的劳动法是当今世界最好的法律。减少工作时间，定期休息，带薪假期和赞助去意大利的旅行作为津贴。
* 在年轻人中推广体育文化，使德国成为体育强国。
* 举办1936年柏林奥运会。
* 希特勒宣布向已婚夫妇提供1000马克(1939年为10个月工资)的最低利息贷款，并免除生育第一个孩子的费用。

* Volkswagen - people's car. Personalized Cars for average germans was laid out in 1937. Volkswagen is an extremely popular brand now.
* German Autobahn(super highways) was introduced in Hitler's era.
* Unemployment was eradicated entirely in pre war period.
* Inflation was at all time low.
* Hitler had forbade German army from using mustard gas or any sort of chemical weapons on enemy forces because of the trauma he suffered in WW1 from mustard gas. As a result, deadly gas warfare of WW 1 was never seen in WW 2.

* 大众，人民的汽车。在1937年问世，为普通德国人设计的个性化汽车。大众现在是一个非常受欢迎的品牌。
* 高速公路是希特勒时代引入的概念。
* 失业现象在战前完全消除了。
* 通胀处于历史最低水平。
* 希特勒曾禁止德国军队对敌军使用芥子气或任何种类的化学武器，因为他在第一次世界大战中受到芥子气的创伤。因此，第一次世界大战中的致命毒气战，没有在二战中出现过。

Duy Truong student of modern world history
3 things I can think of:
1. Body language matters
There is little doubt that Adolf Hitler was one of the finest orators in political history. He had the ability to rouse up millions of people, merely with speeches.
But vocal delivery was only 50% of the message. The rest was body language.
Hitler worked hard to effectively add animation to his delivery. And the results, well, were excellent.
Every speech was a performance, and Hitler sought to master the craft. He breathed lived into words.
2. Reading people’s mood
Hitler was also extremely good at reading the mood of the mass population. He detected bitterness, shame and anger after World War I was ended.
And he devoted his mind and heart to tapping into those emotions.
Intepreting the situation and taking full advantage of it, that’s something we can learn from him.
3. Constant struggle called Life

【回答】研究现代世界史的学生
我能想到的三点：
1. 肢体语言很重要
毫无疑问，阿道夫 · 希特勒是政治史上最优秀的演说家之一。他有能力仅仅通过演讲就唤醒数百万人。
但是声音的传递只占信息的50% ，其余的是肢体语言。
希特勒努力工作，为他的演讲增添了生动的效果，结果非常出色。
每一次演讲都是一次表演，希特勒寻求掌握这门手艺，他的呼吸变成了语言。
2. 读懂人们的情绪
希特勒也非常善于解读大众的情绪。第一次世界大战结束后，他察觉到了痛苦、羞耻和愤怒。
他全身心投入利用这些情感。
了解情况，充分利用这点，这是我们可以从他身上学到的东西。
3. 生存就是竞争

David Rosen PhD Physics & Solid State, City University of New York Graduate Center (1985)
The primary lesson that I got from reading Mein Kampf is that the Holocaust did happen. However, it wasn’t confined to Jews.
There are a lot of Nazi Apologists who claim that Hitler was not trying to kill and enslave people. The claim is that he was a political leader no worse than the others of his time.
The NA’s sometimes claim that he never intended to harm anybody. He was just sticking up for German interests. His homicidal intentions are delusions propagated by Jews. Some NA’s even claim that Hitler loved the people of Eastern Europe! He was just trying to staalize it, is all!
A careful reading of Mein Kampf will convince even the mildly objective that Hitler really was homicidal. He wanted to commit the German people to a worldwide program of death and destruction.
Further, Hitler wanted to be remembered as a monster. He wanted his name to inspire fear. He did not want to be remembered for ‘Germans helping Germans’.
Hitler was not ‘just some regular’ guy. That is what you can learn.

【回答】纽约城市大学研究生中心 物理与固态博士(1985年)
我从阅读《我的奋斗》中得到的主要一课是，大屠杀确实发生了。然而，这并不仅限于犹太人。
有很多纳粹的辩护者声称希特勒并没有试图杀害和奴役人民。有人声称，他是一个政治领导人，并不比他那个时代的其他人差。
纳粹有时声称，他从未打算伤害任何人。他只是在维护德国的利益。他的杀人意图是犹太人宣传的妄想。一些 纳粹人甚至声称希特勒热爱东欧人民！他只是想稳住它，仅此而已！
仔细阅读《我的奋斗》，哪怕只是稍微客观一点的东西，也会让人相信希特勒确实是杀人犯。他想让德国人民参与一项世界范围内的死亡和破坏计划。
此外，希特勒希望人们记住他是一个怪物。他希望自己的名字能激起人们的恐惧。他不想因为“德国人帮助德国人”而被记住。
希特勒不是“普通”人，这是你可以学到的。

Szurdoki Gábor Web designer / Rap artist
Hitler was a personality disordered INFJ, which is the rarest archetype. INFJs are built with a deep wish for good for everyone. Hitler somehow acquired narcissism and other serious personality disorders, but unfortunately, he remained an INFJ with all (or most) of its strengths: unparalelled willpower, strategic talent.
Just to give you hints: Muhammad Ali, Martin Luther King, Mike Tyson are/were also INFJs. Hitler was equally powerful but with a sick moral and deep insecurites as a person.
The world’s luck is that his evilness and egomania, his personality disorder(s) won over his skills.
I do not think that there is anything you can learn from that creature. Maybe, if you are able to seperate his emotionally loaded delusional decisions from the rest.
My advice is, learn from positive role models, not from scumbags.

【回答】网页设计师/说唱艺术家
希特勒有一个性格紊乱的INFJ型人格，这是最罕见的原型。INFJ型人格是怀有对每个人都友好的深切愿望。不知何故，希特勒获得了自恋和其他严重的人格障碍，但不幸的是，他仍然有INFJ型人格，拥有它的所有(或大部分)力量：无与伦比的意志力，战略天赋。
只是给你一些提示：穆罕默德·阿里、马丁·路德·金、迈克·泰森也是INFJ型人格。希特勒也同样强大，但是他的道德观有问题，而且作为一个人他处于极度不安全的状态。
他的邪恶和自大是这个世界的幸运，他的人格障碍胜过了他的技能。
我不认为你能从那个生物身上学到什么。也许吧，如果你能把他那充满情绪妄想的决定和其他区分开来。
我的建议是，向积极的榜样学习，而不是向混蛋学习。

Ethan James Writer (freelance) (2019-present)
He Didn’t Like Smokers
It was largely forgotten for a long time, but Nazis ran one of the first anti-smoking campaigns in modern history. Of course, a large amount of Germans smoked during the general WW2 period, but Hitler had plans to try and phase it out[1] . He didn’t like people smoking around him.
Like seriously, do you seriously think I’m gonna listen to what Adolf Hitler has to say??
Footnotes[1] The Nazis' Forgotten Anti-Smoking Campaign

【回答】作家(自由职业者)(2019年-至今)
他不喜欢吸烟的人。
在很长一段时间里，这点基本上被遗忘了，但是纳粹在现代历史上开展了第一次反吸烟运动。当然，大量德国人在二战期间吸烟，但希特勒曾计划尝试逐步停止吸烟。他不喜欢别人在他身边抽烟。
说真的，你真的认为我会听阿道夫 · 希特勒的话吗？
脚注：纳粹被遗忘的禁烟运动。

Gordon Allen BA followed by JD Economics & European History, Columbia University (1970)
That it was possible to bridge social, economic, and political divides and establish a national spirit that was unified in the belief that all chasm’s in interests were secondary to the good of the country as a whole. Even Hitler’s staunchest military critics after the War conceded that Hitler had created a sense of social unity that greatly strengthened the country and it’s durability during the War.(see secret recordings made of captured german generals in Britain).

【回答】哥伦比亚大学经济与欧洲历史学士(1970年)
可能是弥合社会、经济和政治分歧，建立一种统一的民族精神，相信所有利益分歧都是次要的，而整个国家的利益才是最重要。战后，即使是希特勒最坚定的军事批评家也承认，希特勒创造了一种社会团结感，在战争期间极大地加强了这个国家和它的持久性。(参见英国俘获的德国将军的秘密录音)。

Kyle Dring
Well, this must come as a surprise to some but even though Adolf Hitler wanted to remove all the Jews from Greater German (he didn’t want to kill Jews until later on in his life) and take over the world, the Nazi party ran one of the worlds first anti-smoking campaigns in modern history.
Adolf Hitler was a heavy smoker in his early life—he used to smoke 25 to 40 cigarettes daily—but gave up the habit, concluding that it was "a waste of money".[1]
He didn’t like people smoking. Kill Jews but don’t you dare damage your lungs!
Footnotes[1] Anti-tobacco movement in Nazi Germany - Wikipedia

【回答】
这对某些人来说一定很惊讶，但是尽管阿道夫 · 希特勒想把所有犹太人从大德意志地区赶走(他在晚年才想要杀死犹太人)并接管世界，纳粹党还是发起了现代历史上第一次反吸烟运动。
阿道夫•希特勒早年烟瘾很大，曾经每天吸25到40支香烟，但后来戒掉了，他认为这是“浪费钱”。
他不喜欢别人抽烟。杀死犹太人，但别伤害自己的肺！
纳粹德国禁烟运动-维基百科

Divyam Agarwal
Adolf hitler is regarded as a very cruel person.he had lost his parents when he was very young and ended up living in a flop house he sold paintings and earned a living also he was very poor and had very little money.after the defeat of germany in world war 1 he joined a party And soon became the head of it and after some attempts he finally conquered germany .Adolf hitler was very brave and had a lot of will power even though he was severly harmed by mustard gas and spent some months in hospital he tried serve his country hitler was very patrotic and brave also he had tremendous will power

【回答】
阿道夫 · 希特勒被认为是一个非常残忍的人。他在很小的时候就失去了父母，最后住在一个破旧的房子里，靠卖画谋生。他非常贫穷，没有多少钱。第一次世界大战德国战败后，他加入了一个政党，很快就成为该政党的领导人，经过几次尝试，最终征服了德国。阿道夫 · 希特勒非常勇敢，有很强的意志力，尽管他受到了芥子气的严重伤害，并在医院里呆了几个月，他还想着为国家效力。

Shobhit Shrivastava works at Intel
* Speech has power - No one denies Hitler being a powerful orator. He rose to supremacy by arousing people with his ardent speeches.Thus, good speaking skills help.
* Stay healthy - He never drank or smoked and was very strict about vitamin supplements in his daily diet.And this one is for us to take it in the right way.

【回答】在英特尔工作
* 演讲有力量，没有人否认希特勒是一位强大的演说家。他热情洋溢的演说激起了人们的热情，从而获得了统治地位。因此，良好的演讲技巧会有所帮助。
* 保持健康，他从不饮酒或吸烟，在日常饮食中对维生素补充剂要求非常严格。而这点是我们要用正确的方式来对待的。

Anonymous
His leadership skills were amazing he was a strong leader who always tried to do the best for his people are tried to do the most to make them stronger, and more accomplised. He was a very bad and evil person yes, but his strength in battle tactics proved worthy of the Germans.

【回答】
他的领导能力令人惊叹，他是一个坚强的领导者，总是尽最大努力为他的人民做最好的事情，尽最大努力使他们更强大，更有成就。是的，他是一个非常坏和邪恶的人，但他在战斗战术上的力量被证明是无愧于德国人。

Cindy Holt
What on earth would make you ask a stupid question like that in the first place? While it was before my time, I have studied history and quite honestly believe that anyone who thinks anything good could come from that monster must be psychotic! You need a doctor, right now.

【回答】
究竟是什么让你一开始问这样一个愚蠢的问题？虽然那是在我们时代之前的事，但我研究过历史，而且我十分相信，任何认为能从那个怪物身上学到什么好东西的人，一定是精神病！你现在需要去看医生。

Robert Holmén Father was a WWII chemist
Why Hitler? Why is Hitler the one you are hungering to find some positive factoid about?
There’s a thousand other wretched, malevolent, malign humans out there who were nice to their dogs or once voted to properly fund the local school system.
Why not them?
Your devotion to trying to rehabilitate Hitler is a sad illness. He is undeserving of rehabilitation and you should stop the world’s time.

【回答】父亲是二战时期的化学家
为什么是希特勒? 为什么你想从希特勒身上找出一些积极的事情？
世界上还有成千上万其他可怜的、恶毒的、邪恶的人类对他们自己的狗很好，或者曾经投票支持为当地的教育系统提供资金。
为什么不是他们？
你致力于恢复希特勒的名誉是一种可悲的疾病。他不值得洗白，你应该停止浪费全世界的时间。